Should You Get a Wedding Video? Why It’s So Difficult to Decide

Wedding Video Advice

If you’re trying to decide whether to hire a wedding videographer, you’ve probably already heard every opinion imaginable.

  • “You’ll regret it if you don’t!”
  • “We barely watch ours.”
  • “It’s worth every penny.”
  • “Photos are enough.”

And none of that actually helps you. Because the truth is, there is no universal right answer.

Some couples can’t imagine their wedding without a film. Others don’t think about it at all. Some book a videographer last minute and are thrilled they did. Others rush into hiring someone just to check it off the list and end up disappointed.

If you’re stuck, we’ve got help for you—and it’s not the same thing you’ve read everywhere else. We want to help you make a genuine choice that’s yours and yours alone so you can feel confident and empowered.

Because the truth is—you are a great decision-maker. We all get in our own heads at times.

I want to tell you what happens at each stage of planning, the common hurdles, and how to move past them—so you can plan without stressing out… and move on. No one likes to be stuck.

That’s why this isn’t another article telling you “Yes! Get a video!” Instead, I want to lay out the actual decision points couples face when deciding on videography—so you know what to expect at every step.


First Decision Point: Choosing a Wedding Location

It’s easy to assume you can set your budget first and find vendors to match—but location dictates costs more than couples expect. The venue, vendors, and even logistics are all influenced by the area’s cost of living and demand. Choosing a high-end destination means working within a high-end pricing structure, which isn’t always obvious at first.

The Decision:

  • I want to have a destination wedding on Cape Cod and get married at Chatham Bars Inn because I have such fond memories of our Chatham vacations and have always dreamed of a South Lawn tented wedding. I would LOVE for everyone I love to experience the place I love at the same time. I can’t think of anything more meaningful and special.
  • We could get married locally at a ballroom. It’s very pretty but feels kind of generic. It’s not quite me. I know it’s easy and practical, but it’s not what I dreamt of.

The Reality:

  • Your location influences every cost associated with your wedding, from venue pricing to vendor rates and logistics.
  • High-demand locations naturally come with higher costs—vendors in luxury markets aren’t trying to “get away with high pricing.” Their pricing reflects the actual cost of owning and operating a business in that market.
  • Many couples assume they can set a budget first and find vendors to match, only to realize that location drives pricing more than expected.
  • Understanding this upfront can help avoid sticker shock later.

Second Decision Point: Your Vendor Priorities

Every couple has different vendor priorities. Some know from the start that videography is a must-have, while others see it as a nice-to-have. If videography is high on your list, you have time and options to find the right fit. If it’s lower, the number of available choices shrinks the longer you wait.

The Decision:

  • Videography is a top priority, and I want to book the best filmmaker for my wedding.
  • Videography isn’t a top priority, so I’ll book it later—if I even decide to.

The Reality:

  • If videography is a top priority, you get first choice of the best filmmakers, access to sought-after talent, and the flexibility to find a style that truly fits you.
  • If videography isn’t a priority, it often gets pushed down the list—which means fewer choices and more compromises.
  • The later you book, the fewer options you’ll have.
  • Boutique filmmakers book up quickly. Mass-market companies will always have availability—but that’s because they scramble to fill last-minute gaps, sometimes hiring unvetted freelancers the night before a wedding.
  • Some couples roll the dice on a mass-market company and end up perfectly happy. Others get stuck with an inexperienced videographer who disrupts the timeline, frustrates their planner, or misses key moments. It’s a gamble—one that some are fine taking, but it’s worth knowing the risks.

Third Decision Point: What’s “Reasonable Pricing”?

Figuring out what’s “reasonable” for wedding videography isn’t easy.

Unlike other major purchases, there’s no standardized pricing guide, and most couples have never hired a videographer—or any other wedding vendor before. So they do what makes sense—they gather pricing from different vendors and try to find the middle ground. The problem? That middle ground doesn’t account for the how and why behind the numbers. All the different business models, skill levels, the client experience provided, and the markets these vendors live in.

The Decision:

  • Let’s compare all vendor prices and find the average.
  • Let’s go with the cheapest option.
  • Let’s book the vendor we actually want, even if they’re above the average, because the experience they give us will be worth it.

The Reality:

  • There is no one “reasonable price”—only the actual cost of expertise, experience, and running a videography business in a specific market.
  • Averages don’t tell the full story. Whatever number you get will be skewed because it doesn’t account for different business models, skill levels, or experience.
  • Vendors in high-cost areas charge more because their cost of doing business is higher.
  • They aren’t inflating prices just because it’s a wedding. Their pricing reflects real expenses—including permits, insurance, staffing, travel, and accommodations.
  • This is especially true for Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard, where just getting to the island costs videographers money and time.
  • Some videographers don’t stay or are asked not to say overnight to cut costs (even by some wedding planners… not good)—but that means leaving your wedding early which puts a rush on your big important moments, or worse, risking ferry cancellations and not showing up. These are real trade-offs couples don’t always consider.

Lobster Rolls & Wedding Videos: The Price Isn’t the Problem—It’s the Value

A Cape Cod lobster roll might feel expensive at $33. But that succulent, tender lobster was caught in Cape Cod Bay that same morning by Frank, a generational fisherman who prioritizes sustainability, throws back undersized lobsters, and knows exactly where his catch is coming from. When you buy from him, you’re not just getting better quality—you’re supporting a business that directly contributes to the local economy and culture.

Compare that to a Mystic, Connecticut McDonald’s, where they’ve sold lobster rolls for under $15 in the past. That lobster? Who knows where it came from, when it was caught, or if it’s even real lobster meat.

The price isn’t the problem—it’s whether the quality, sourcing, experience, and trust factor justify it. And it’s the same with videography.

A $5,000 mass-market company might seem like a decent deal next to an $8,000 boutique filmmaker, but what’s missing? What’s actually in the package—and what’s been sacrificed to make that price work?

When you hire a boutique filmmaker, you’re not just getting a better film—you’re working with someone who knows the area, understands the nuances of your venue, and has built relationships with other vendors to make your day run smoothly. You’re supporting a business that stakes its reputation on every wedding it films, rather than one that funnels bookings through a corporate pipeline.


How to Tell If a Videographer’s Pricing Matches What You Need

How to Tell If a Videographer’s Pricing Matches What You Need
Instead of asking, “Is this too expensive?” try asking:

  • Does this videographer specialize in the style I want?
    • Why? Just because they can do it doesn’t mean they do it well. If they specialize in your style, you’re getting their best work—not just an attempt to match a trend.
  • How involved are they in the process?
    • Why? If you’re working directly with the person crafting your film, you’ll have a more tailored experience. If it’s a larger mass market company, your experience depends on who you get—and you often won’t know who that is until just before your wedding day.
  • What is their reputation with planners and other vendors?
    • Why? High-end planners don’t gamble on bad experiences. If a videographer comes highly recommended by other professionals, it’s a sign they’re reliable, easy to work with, and deliver consistently great results.
  • Will they still be in business in five years?
    • Why? It sounds dramatic, but wedding vendors go under all the time. If a business isn’t priced sustainably, they might not be around long enough to deliver your film—or even finish editing it. This helps assess your risk factor.
  • What’s included in the price?
    • Why? A lower price with unlimited coverage, all the films, and raw footage isn’t a deal if it comes at the cost of experience, attention to detail, or a videographer who actually works well with your team.
    • What’s often missing?
      • Time and care in the edit – Fast turnaround often means generic, rushed editing with little thought to storytelling, this is how films end up feeling cheesy.
      • Personalized service – If you never actually talk to your videographer before your wedding, that’s a red flag.
      • A skilled team – Mass-market companies fill gaps with whoever is available, sometimes hiring freelancers last-minute.
      • Reliability and consistency – A big package at a bargain price usually means cutting corners somewhere.

Understanding what’s included helps you compare value—not just cost. Would you rather have “everything” with compromises or the right things done exceptionally well?

Asking these questions shifts your focus from “What’s the average price?” to “What am I actually getting?”—which is the key to making a decision you won’t regret.

Bottom Line?

If you’re getting married in an expensive area, your videographer’s cost will reflect that—just like rent, groceries, and, yes, lobster rolls.


The Waffle Maker Test (Yes, Really.)

You need a waffle maker. You’ve got two options:

  • The cheap one – Costs less, which means extra money for those jeans you’ve been eyeing.
  • The really good one – Costs more, but it’s well-designed, easy to clean, and makes perfect waffles every time.

The Decision:

At first, the cheap one seems like the smarter choice. Waffles are waffles, right?

But then, you start thinking about it… you’ve had these types of waffle makers before.

The Reality:

  • The batter sticks. You have to pry your waffle out in pieces.
  • It’s impossible to clean. You pick at stuck-on pieces with a paper towel and a toothpick.
  • There’s a crust all around the edges from overflowed batter that hardened like cement.
  • You stop making waffles as often. You forgot how much of a pain it was.

Now you think about the other one—the one you nearly ruled out because it’s more than double the price.

  • Nothing sticks. You never have to pry out broken waffles.
  • Nothing ever overflows. A well-designed machine prevents it.
  • It’s effortless to clean. No toothpicks. No crust. No swearing under your breath.
  • You make waffles more often because it’s actually enjoyable.

Some people will still pick the cheap one. And that’s OK. Because, sometimes, you just need a stupid cheap waffle maker. But now, they’re making the choice knowing exactly what they’re signing up for—no pressure, no surprises, no regrets.


The Regret Check: Short-Term vs. Long-Term

OK, so we know how to check for regret when shopping for waffle makers (you’re welcome I hope you have the best waffles now) but, eh, a video isn’t a $200 waffle maker. It can come with a little heavier regret than it being annoying to clean and using it less.

Right now, $8,000 could go toward something else—a honeymoon upgrade, home savings, paying off some other wedding costs or upgrading to get some sweet bathroom flowers (totally a thing).

Fifteen years from now? That same $8,000 might feel like nothing compared to how often your film has been watched.

Your friends. Your parents. Your kids. Your sister’s kids.

It becomes part of the family’s memories—not just yours.

Ask yourself:

Am I making this choice based on what matters most today or what will matter most over time?

Which trade-off will sit better with me in 10 years?

If you’re struggling to answer that, try flipping the question:

Imagine you already have the film. Would you give it up for $8,000?

If the answer is yes, then the money is more important right now.

If the answer is absolutely not, then you already know the value is there.

Or imagine you didn’t get a video, with everything that has changed in your life… Would you pay $8,000 to have it back?

This is a trick I use for almost every big purchase I struggle with. And on a personal note—trust me: as someone who never thought she’d care much about her own family memories due to complicated family issues… that all changed when my mother died. If you’d asked me in my 20s, I would have bet anything that would never happen.

Growth is real, and learning that the hard way was not fun. But that was my reality. Yours might be different. And that’s the whole point—only you know what will matter most to you, and only you will know if you’ll be okay with your answer—even 20 years later.

If the answer is no, you’re good.

If the answer is yes, that tells you something.

The Decision Hack

If you can’t decide between two things, act like you’ve already made the decision.

If you feel relief, you made the right choice.

  • If you feel relief, you made the right choice.
  • If you feel dread or disappointment, you didn’t.

There is no right answer—only the right answer for you. At the end of the day, all that matters is that you make a choice you can live with. You’ve got this.

If you’re having a small wedding or elopement, you might be wondering if video is worth it for an intimate gathering. We break that down in detail here: Should I Hire a Videographer for My Small Wedding?

error: This content is protected by copyright. Please attribute my writing and provide a link to this article as reference when using my words.